Something is Killing the Children vol. 1 (ARC Review)

With a slight sci-fi and Stranger Things feel, Something is Killing the children vol. 1, is the start of a classic, monster-killing horror series. 

This bind-up of the first five issues brings us to the small town of Archer’s Peak, where children are disappearing and no one knows why. Except for James, that is, who witnessed the death of his friends at the many hands of a monster that adults can’t seem to see. Haunted by his memories of that night, James joins forces with the mysterious new woman in town, Erica Slaughter, who seems to know more about the monsters than anyone else. 

The art style of this series is something I haven’t quite seen before, a little sketchy and grim, mixed with a classic-comic-book style. The way frames overflowed and covered whole, two-page spreads was an interesting tactic that took some getting used to (mostly because of my PDF version), but created another dynamic level to the story that I enjoyed, even if it didn’t seem to serve any specific purpose. Dark and ominous, but for its splashes of red, this book has no problem jumping right in and highlighting the gore, although it’s not realistic enough to stir much of a scare in anyone who isn’t diving into horror for the first time.

Erica Slaughter is an interesting character, who ends up being at the complete center and driving force of the story. Alone, she supplies not only the majority of the plot but almost all of the tension and suspense. In fact, the mystery of who she is, where she came from, and why she has devoted her life to chasing monsters is honestly the only thing that kept me reading. Oh, and the stuffed animal octopus, which was actually the most interesting part of it all, even if we only brush the surface of what the heck its deal is.  The other characters are either underdeveloped, serve only a particular and stereotypical horror-trope role, or both. 

The pacing in comparison to almost any other work in this genre is also very slow. Part of this is because we know too much at the start of the story, when the monster is almost immediately revealed. The rest is because of its predictability and the limited tension that rides mostly on readers waiting for a fight scene. Although the art style is well-suited for horror, and has a certain dark charm, the scenes don’t depict action particularly well, and end up feeling somewhat stagnant, especially for a series that relies on the bad-assery and cool factor of a monster-slayer beating up creatures. If the five issues hadn’t been all together, I can’t say I would’ve continued after no. 1. A story like this needs more of a hook to get readers to keep buying issues…and Something just didn’t have it.

Still, I believe 100% that this series would get better in following volumes based on how this one ends. But, after being given so little in this beginning installment and feeling very much unafraid, I can’t say that I would take the time to keep reading. 

With a nice art style but forgettable, and lacking in action, I rated Something is Killing the Children vol. 1, 2.5 out of 5 stars.  However, fans of the Sabrina comics may like this. 

Thank you to Netgalley and Boom!Studios for an early copy in exchange for an honest review!